Nintendo Switch vs. Atari Lynx Which is Better

By samson7point1

The Showdown


The Nintendo Switch has been in the hands of players for a couple of months now.  The gaming press has carried stories of shortages and stock flying off the shelves, but when you strip away the hype and marketing, how does it hold up against one of the best handhelds of all time, the Atari Lynx?

Don't let the fact that both machines feature horizontal orientation with controls on the sides fool you, these are very different devices.  We'll rank each system according to a series of 6 crucial criteria to see how they really stack up.


1. Size

Top: The Atari Lynx featuring ergonomic contouring, and ambidextrous controls. Bottom: The Nintendo Switch featuring a more stylish, but somewhat ergonomically compromised design exclusively for the right-handed. 

The Switch takes up a 9.5x4 inch surface area and is .55 inches thick, while the Lynx is 10.75x4.25 inches and 1.5 inches thick.  At first glance they are similar enough in size that it may seem like neither would enjoy a significant advantage but with a larger surface-to-screen ratio and nearly 3 times the thickness, the Lynx allows for a much sturdier and comfortable grip and more room to place your fingers while Switch players need to keep their digits much nearer the edge and pinched at a much more acute angle to grip the thinner handheld.

Advantage: Lynx


2. Erogonomics


The Lynx features a D-Pad and allows the screen to be inverted to accommodate left-handed players as well as right-handed players.  Sound volume is controlled with an analog potentiometer, allowing for an infinite range of adjustment.  The Switch also features multiple controller orientation options, but sadly none are designed with lefties in mind. The Switch tries to make up for its lack of a D-Pad with numerous buttons, analog control sticks.  The stick placement of the analog stick on the right joy-con was chosen to allow the right joy-con to operate as a standalone controller or as the right-side controls for the console when attached.  Some users find the right-analog stick placement to be an uncomfortable unwelcome compromise.  Volume control on the switch is digital, limiting the adjustment to a stair-step range of 30 different volume settings.

Advantage: Lynx


3. Screen


The Lynx sports a color 3.5 inch screen with a resolution of 160x102, while the Switch has a 6.2 inch color screen with a resolution of 1280x720.  If you do the math you'll notice pixels on the Lynx are 5x the size of pixels on the Switch!  This means more visible surface per pixel and better pixel definition.

As you can see from these direct comparison screenshots, the pixels are clearly visible on the Lynx screen, but basically impossible to see on the Switch.

With it's enormous pixel size, each individual pixel on the Lynx is clearly visible.

Shown at actual resolution, the Switch pixels are practically microscopic.


Technical details

Switch
pixel width 0.0042
pixel height 0.0042

Lynx
pixel width 0.0203
pixel height 0.0184

Advantage: Lynx

4. Power and Battery Life


The Lynx has its power socket on the top, so the unit can be placed flush on the table while it is connected to wall power.  Lynx average battery life is 4.5 hours.  The switch places its power socket on the bottom of the unit, so it cannot be placed flush on a table while connected to wall power.  Average battery life for the switch is 4.25 hours putting it nearly on-par with the Lynx, however the Lynx has changeable batteries making practical battery life infinite provided you bring enough spares.

Advantage: Lynx

5. Game Packaging

Left: Switch games come in a protective plastic clamshell for safe and easy storage. Right: Lynx games are shipped in fragile cardboard boxes which do not provide reusable protective storage.
While the game packages for both handhelds offer artwork of similar size and quality, the Switch packaging doubles as a somewhat durable and reusable storage case while Lynx owners are expected to provide an alternative means of storing games.

Advantage: Switch

5. Inside the Package - The Games

Lynx cartridges are 2.4x2.2 inches in size allowing for labels with artwork that don't require a magnifying glass to read, and they also taste pretty neutral.  While the Switch uses extremely easy to misplace cartridges 1.25 x .86 inches in size with microscopic artwork and they taste fantastically awful.  Lynx cartridges feature the pin connectors on the front side so it is very easy to tell when/if they have become dirty or need cleaning.  The pins on the Switch cartridge are hidden on the back side.  Nintendo's solution seems to have been recessing the pins to prevent surface dirt accumulation, but this also makes them extremely difficult to clean should the need arise.

Left: Switch cartridges are too small to read unassisted.  Center: Lynx Cartridges feature legible artwork and easy to inspect and clean pins.  Right: Lynx is the only one of the two to ship all of its games with helpful instruction manuals.

Also once we get into the package we discover another corner cut by the big N - switch games do not come with manuals.  In contrast every Lynx game ships with a manual.

Advantage: Lynx

6. Cartridge Selection

At present this is a no-contest category.  With it's massive selection of 74 game cartridges the Lynx completely eclipses Nintendo's plucky upstart which is still flagging behind with fewer than 10 titles available as of this writing.  It should be noted, however, that the number of titles offered for the Switch is expected to increase and may even eventually be on-par with the vast selection available to Lynx owners today.

Advantage: Lynx


Conclusion

After winning 5 out of 6 categories, it's no surprise that Atari's powerhouse comes out on top of this one.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What I've Learned Fixing Optical Drives

By samson7point1
So You Want to Fix an Optical Drive If you found this page looking for advice on how to fix an optical drive, you might be in luck.  There's a lot of information and prognostication out there these days that might tell you fixing a laser mechanism is a losing proposition, but the fact is that in many cases these drives are completely fixable. Over the past decade I've begun fixing a optical drive failures in a wide variety of hardware. In the process I've learned a thing or two about a thing or two and I've compiled my findings here in the hopes they may help someone else. Full disclosure: I'm a technical professional, just not in the field of electrical engineering.  I do this as a hobby.  My skills and information comes from a lifetime of curiosity and decades of reading manuals, reading books, learning from experts and practical application. My success rate in repairing these drives and restoring them to original function seems to be in direct opposition to popul...
Read more

FM Towns PC ODE - Grey Tower Wizard Installation Notes And Review

By samson7point1
Image
The Gray Tower Wizard is an Optical Drive Emulator (ODE) for FM Towns PCs, not to be confused with the FM Towns Marty (which is a stripped-down and consolized version of the PCs) or the Doc Brown ODE for Marty (which is made by the same person).  The FM Towns PCs have dual floppy drives and the ability to add RAM which makes them capable of running more complex or resource-heavy games than the Marty. How Do You Get One? The kit including shipping ran me 150 Euro.  Ordering one is basically the same process as the GDEmu, Rhea, Phoebe and Doc Brown.  I had never ordered anything from Deunan before but I'm more than familiar with the popular complaints about it being difficult.  It's not like ordering something from Amazon, but I didn't find it to be very difficult at all.   I signed up for blog updates, waited until he announced he was going to sell them, then refreshed the Wizard Ordering page  until he activated it.  When he did, the ordering page...
Read more

ColecoVision RGB Mod [Updated]

By samson7point1
Image
[Updated June 2020]  As with all hobbies these things can be learning processes. After initially completing this mod, I discovered some new things and made some changes.  Primarily, I've re-incorporated the RF box for actual composite video, figured out the black & white picture problem, added a buffering capacitor to the audio output and tapped the audio from a different location to maintain compatibility with the ColecoVision Expansion Module #1.  The Expansion module doesn't work with RGB out, but now it's at least usable with composite Genesis 2 cables.  Background ColecoVision wasn't something I had or even played growing up, but several years ago someone gave me one.  Since its only AV output is RF and that makes it hard to have multiple systems connected at once, it sat in a box for about 10 years until I stumbled across Ben Heck's tutorial on a very straightforward composite video mod. The Picture Quality Produced by the Ben Heck composite ...
Read more